Carilley Estate

www.carilleyestate.com.au
Lot 23 Hyem Road
Herne Hill
Western Australia 6056
Phone : 08 9296 6190
Fax : 08 9296 3890



On approaching we saw a full car park and were anticipating some numbers at the tasting counter: this happened to be deserted in favour of the restaurant next door, which was doing a brisk trade indeed. Our friendly attendant knew very little of wine in any shape or form, but was happy to pour as we requested.

2006 Chenin Blanc $18
We know what this grape can do, and Carilley wasn’t it. This wine was just another light, summery, easy drinking beverage.

2007 Verdi $19
A blend of Viognier and Chenin Blanc. Bland, slightly acid.

2006 Oaked Chardonnay, $24
Better. A light wine, but with some grip. The oaking must have been light, as we tasted no hint of the expected vanilla, citrus or oaken tannins.

2006 Crucible $26
This interesting wine is a blend of Sangiovese, Merlot and Malbec. The blend works well, compliments to the winemaker. Again spicy tastes, but the wine came across as delicate, smooth and velvety. The best of Carilley. Recommended.

2003 Shiraz $23
The most polite thing I can say about this wine is that it should have been withdrawn. This wine was oxidized and I still have the rank taste in my mouth. Dreadful.

2005 Reserve Shiraz, $37
This wine was light in taste, colour and texture. A lightweight, indeed. I could not understand how this wine could deserve either the “Reserve” title or its whopping price tag.

1997 Damask, $50
A fortified wine of golden colour. Sultana nose, good flavours of muscadel and raisins. The alcohol is raw and has no integration with the fruit, resulting in a hefty after-burn in the throat. Very expensive for the price.

Verdict: Swan valley winemakers should have respect for the consumers of their products: we vote with our wallets. A wine made from a specific varietal should taste like that varietal and additionally have its own, unique characteristics from the terroir as well as the micro-climate. A range of identical-tasting, light and fluffy wines at prices that are consistently beaten by your neighbours will not ensure long-term profitability. I sincerely trust the Carilley restaurant is a money-spinner.